Former bodega clerk Jose Alba joined the families of other crime victims and their supporters Monday in railing against Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg at a contentious GOP-led House Judiciary Committee hearing targeting the lefty prosecutor.
The group testified at a special congressional âfield hearingâ at the Javits Convention Center in Manhattan, putting Bragg on the hot seat in front of a national audience.
The DA was not at the hearing.
The eight people who spoke or provided statements decried Big Apple crime and Braggâs controversial alleged lax policies, which critics say favor criminals over law and order.
Those testifying ran the gamut â from victims, their families and advocates to law-enforcement officials:
Alba, who is in his early 60s, was initially charged with murder by Braggâs office for fatally stabbing a man who attacked him behind the counter at the store where he worked in July. Alba spent a week on Rikers Island before the charges against him were dropped after widespread outcry.
âI took pride in the hard work I put in every day at the store to earn my own money and support myself and my family,â Alba, who was at Mondayâs hearing, testified through his lawyer. âThat is when I encountered a true and real threat to my life after I simply told a woman that she could not have potato chips because her payment was declined.
âI was face to face with her boyfriend who seemed ready to kill me,â he said. âHe attacked me violently, threw me around the store. The woman stabbed me herself. I truly believe they were there to kill me.â
Jennifer Harrison, the founder of Victims Rights NY, suffered through her boyfriend and his pal being murdered in New Jersey in 2005. Three brothers were arrested and charged with the slayings, but only one of them ended up serving time in prison. Harrison has been an advocate for crime victims ever since.
âNobody wanted to listen to us, the victims who have to live with the consequences of these decisions for the rest of our lives, when we warned of the harm this would cause,â she said of soft-on-crime policies. âVictims have no voice in politics or government.â
Madeline Brame is the chairwoman of the Victims Rights Reform Council and the mother of former US Army vet Hason Corea, who was beaten and stabbed to death in Harlem in 2018. Bragg inherited the case after taking office in 2022 â and cut deals with three of the four suspects, all siblings.
âHe dismissed â completely dismissed â gang assault and murder indictments against two of the defendants clearly on video participating in the brutal, savage slaughter of my son,â Brame said of the DA. âAnd as far as the Manhattan District Attorneyâs Office, if heâs receiving one penny of federal dollars, you need to pull that funding until he starts doing his damn job and prosecuting crime.â
Robert Holden, a Democratic New York City councilman representing District 30 in Queens and a member of the councilâs bipartisan âCommon Sense Caucus, is a proponent of rolling back aspects of New Yorkâs controversial bail statute and supports granting judges additional powers to set bail.
âWe have repeat offenders receiving lenient sentences and committing multiple crimes shortly after being released,â Holden said âFrom the day he took office, it seems Alvin Braggâs top priority was to keep criminals out of jail and free to roam the streets.â
Rebecca Fischer, executive director of New Yorkers Against Gun Violence, a group that advocates for stricter gun laws including background checks, intervention and prevention services, told the committee that New York ranks 47th out of the 50 states in gun-violence rates.
âTraffickers go elsewhere to source guns quickly and illegally because gun purchasers are required to go through a background check and licensing process in New York,â she noted. âThe national gun-trafficking crisis is largely the result of weak gun laws in other states and the fact that Congress has not enacted comprehensive federal gun-reform laws.â
Paul DiGiacomo, president of the New York Cityâs Detectivesâ Endowment Association, has been among the most vocal critics of state bail-reform measures that critics say allow more dangerous criminals back onto the streets, where the NYPD is forced to deal with them.
âThe same people are being arrested over and over again for violent crime,â he told the committee. âThey need to be held in jail. There has been a reckless disregard for the law that has led to unprecedented gun violence, robberies, car-jacking, home invasions, burglaries, shoplifting and disturbances by the mentally ill.â
Barry Borgen is the father of Joseph Borgen, who was attacked and brutally beaten in an anti-Semitic attack near Times Square in 2021. Joseph Borgenâs attackers later cut plea deals with Braggâs office.
âI sit here in front of the committee with the two-year anniversary of the attack rapidly approaching to speak of the ongoing struggle with Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg,â the elder Borgen said.
âWhile the delays and continued hold-ups in the legal case are discouraging, it is the sweetheart slap-on-the-wrist deal offered to one of the attackers in my sonâs case that is exemplary of DA Braggâs incompetence when it comes to carrying out justice,â he told the committee.
Jim Kessler is co-founder and senior vice president for policy of Third Way, a progressive policy think tank which has addressed national gun policy and trends. He argued that New York gun and crime rates are favorable compared to other states, including many red states.
âIf we wanted a hearing about the ravages of crime, why arenât we in Baton Rouge or Louisville, where five people were murdered in the blink of an eye in a mass shooting at a downtown bank?â he said.
Or in the murder capital of California,â Kessler said. âWhich is not Los Angeles or San Francisco or Oakland ⌠but in [House] Speaker [Kevin] McCarthyâs district of Kern County, with its county seat of Bakersfield.â